I remember feeling uneasy when I saw a judge criticize a mother for lacking teaching qualifications to homeschool her three children. The judge argued that homeschooling should be reserved for professionals with proper credentials. The plaintiff defended her decision, saying she could provide a better, more personalized education for her children at home.
Naturally, I was upset by the judge’s comments, but they didn’t surprise me. This debate highlights the ongoing controversy surrounding homeschooling and whether it is a valid form of education.
When I homeschool my daughter, I often hear internal voices, like the judge’s, questioning the validity of my choice. Unfortunately, these doubts resurface every time I teach her. As a homeschooling parent, I lack formal teaching credentials despite having a bachelor’s degree.
This judge’s judgment is why I unconsciously assigned so much schoolwork to my daughter during her kindergarten year. I didn’t realize until the end of the year that she had completed an excessive amount. It was the negative reactions and judgment I received from others when I told them I homeschooled that motivated me to push her through an excessive amount of schoolwork in kindergarten.
I was unconsciously trying to show others who think like the judge that homeschooling is effective by giving my daughter an excessive amount of schoolwork. Simultaneously, I was trying to keep up with other parents whose children were educated through traditional schooling methods.
This constant fear of being judged caused me to push my daughter unnecessarily. The large volume of schoolwork I assigned her in kindergarten began to affect our mother-daughter relationship. She became uninterested, defiant, and unhappy, and the excessive workload created unnecessary stress for both of us.
It’s important to note that many successful homeschooling parents do not have traditional teaching credentials but still provide high-quality education for their children. Education and credentials should not be the sole measure of a person’s ability to teach and nurture their children. Every family should have the right to choose the best education option for their children without feeling inadequate or judged.
As parents, it is our responsibility to tailor our children’s education to their needs and abilities rather than focusing solely on completing tasks and meeting arbitrary standards. Homeschooling should provide a personalized and enriching education, not merely replicate traditional school systems.
We should not let others dictate our choices, especially when it comes to our children and their education. While it’s natural to seek validation from others, we must not let their opinions make us doubt our abilities as parents or educators.
Looking back, I realize I should have focused on what was best for my daughter and our family, rather than trying to please everyone else. The lesson I’ve carried forward is simple: trust your instincts and make decisions that align with your own values and goals.
I have come to realize that the most important thing is to trust my decision to homeschool my daughter and not be swayed by others’ opinions. I know what is best for my child and have seen the positive impact homeschooling has had on her education and personal growth. I no longer feel the need to justify my choices to others and have learned to let go of any negative comments or doubts from those who disagree. My daughter’s happiness and success are my top priority, and I am confident in my ability to provide her with a fulfilling and valuable education through homeschooling.
I now understand the importance of balance and allowing children to learn through play and real-life experiences. Young children don’t need to spend hours sitting at a desk completing worksheets. Homeschooling should be an opportunity to create a personalized, meaningful education for our children, not merely to replicate traditional school methods. From now on, I will focus on providing my daughter with a well-rounded education that includes hands-on learning and exploration. Throughout our homeschooling journey, we will continue to learn and grow.
Photo Courtesy
India Akua Mendonça is a stay-at-home mother who loves reading, exploring new places, going to the beach, dining out, and listening to bossa nova music. She received her A.A. in Liberal Arts from Chabot Community College and her B.A. in Black Studies from the University of California, Santa Barbara. Before becoming a wife and mother, India worked as a Document Specialist at the Martin Luther King, Jr. Research and Education Institute at Stanford University. She and her husband purchased a home in Lake County in 2012, and in 2017, they married each other in the living room of their lovely home. She is currently a homeschool teacher to her eight-year-old daughter, and she enjoys every minute she spends witnessing and cultivating her daughter’s education. India is grateful for both the choice and the chance to educate her daughter at home. She resides in Clearlake Oaks, CA, with her husband Marco, their daughter, a bunny, a cat, and four birds.
